is told to paralyze a cheerleading rival to become captain.

is told to falsely accuse her guidance counselor of a crime to ensure her spot at Yale.

is instructed to leak nudes of her crush's girlfriend. Watch American Horror Stories S02E05 WEBRip x26...

You can stream "Bloody Mary" and the rest of the anthology series on major platforms:

The legendary urban legend gets a dark, historical makeover in the fifth episode of Season 2. Titled "Bloody Mary," this standout entry departs from the typical high-school ghost story to deliver a chilling narrative rooted in history and the cost of human desire. The Story: Be Careful What You Wish For is told to paralyze a cheerleading rival to become captain