My Reviews ★

: Use a format that clearly shows the reviewer's original comment followed by your response and the changes you made in the manuscript.

If you have been asked to peer-review someone else's work, your goal is to provide a constructive and objective evaluation. My Reviews

: Clearly state what the paper does well (e.g., novel methodology, clear writing, significant results). : Use a format that clearly shows the

: List technical errors, typos, or formatting issues in a separate, numbered list for easy reference. : List technical errors, typos, or formatting issues

: Remain polite and professional, even if you disagree with a reviewer's comments.

: You must respond to every single point raised by each reviewer. Ignoring comments is a common reason for final rejection.

: If you choose not to make a suggested change, provide a clear, evidence-based explanation for why you didn't.