Critics and fans have largely praised the cover for its authenticity. Rather than a mere imitation, it is viewed as a "stunning rendition" that uses Fender's "raw voice" to convey the song's fervent feeling. By integrating his own "wall of sound" style into the arrangement, Fender successfully bridges the gap between 80s heartland rock and modern indie sensibilities.
: The track highlights the deep, complementary tones of both artists. Fender noted that they spent time practicing their harmonies "in the loos backstage" while on tour to ensure they captured the right emotional weight. Im On Fire - Sam Fender - Apple Music Home Session - Audio
The decision to cover Springsteen was a bold acknowledgement of a comparison that has followed Fender throughout his career. Often dubbed the "Geordie Springsteen" for his anthemic, working-class narratives, Fender admitted that performing the song wouldn't "do [himself] any favors with the Bruce comparisons," but he felt compelled to celebrate his "favorite artist of all time". Artistic Interpretation and Collaboration Critics and fans have largely praised the cover
While the original Springsteen version is characterized by a taut, minimalist restlessness, Fender and Le’aupepe transform it into a rich, vocal-driven experience. : The track highlights the deep, complementary tones