Icarly S01e05 -

Carly's grandfather visits and decides that Spencer is too irresponsible to be her guardian after seeing a series of mishaps—including Spencer accidentally setting fire to a "Hamin" (a ham-shaped fan). Key Moments:

In the original series, Season 1 Episode 5 is titled . It focuses on the emotional core of the Shay family's living arrangement. iCarly s01e05

Spencer presents a detailed folder of Carly’s life (allergies, vitamins, and homework schedules) to prove his competence. Carly's grandfather visits and decides that Spencer is

The fifth episode of varies significantly depending on whether you are watching the original Nickelodeon series or the 2021 Paramount+ revival. Original Series (2007): " iWanna Stay With Spencer " Spencer presents a detailed folder of Carly’s life

After seeing Spencer's dedication and hearing Carly’s plea, Grandad Shay agrees to let her stay in Seattle. Revival Series (2021): " iRobot Wedding "

Watch these reviews and fan discussions to see how the two versions of the show compare:

In the 2021 revival, Season 1 Episode 5 is titled . It brings back a classic villain for a more adult storyline.